Buyers
Rent or buy: which builds more wealth?
The calculator follows two households with the same money at the start: one buys, the other rents and invests the savings. Change the assumptions to see each household's net worth and the year buying pulls ahead.
Comparison
Your rent versus your purchase
Net worth after 7 years
Buy
$257,427
Rent
$257,342
Buying comes out ahead by $84. Buying catches up with renting in year 7.
- Money spent on purchase day
- $64,742
- Mortgage payment per month
- $2,825
- CMHC premium (added to the loan)
- $15,345
| Year | Buy | Rent |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | $67,528 | $89,553 |
| 2 | $96,413 | $115,213 |
| 3 | $126,350 | $141,751 |
| 4 | $157,377 | $169,199 |
| 5 | $189,536 | $197,591 |
| 6 | $222,871 | $226,960 |
| 7 | $257,427 | $257,342 |
First purchase? The HBP and the FHSA can help build the down payment. See the First-time buyers page
The starting amounts are example assumptions: replace them with yours. Estimate only.
How it works
What the calculator compares
The buying side
On purchase day: down payment, welcome tax for the chosen city, QST on the CMHC premium and the notary. Then every month: mortgage, taxes, insurance and maintenance. Net worth is the home's value minus the loan balance.
The renting side
The renter invests, from day one, the money the buyer spent. Each month, whoever pays less invests the difference at the chosen return.
The break-even year
It is the first year the buyer's net worth reaches the renter's. The lower the appreciation or the higher the investment return, the later it comes.
What is not included
Selling costs at the end, tax on investment gains, major unexpected repairs and rate increases at renewal. The starting assumptions are examples, not forecasts.
First purchase?
The HBP and the FHSA can help build the down payment. The First-time buyers page explains both, with the official links.
The right time also depends on your area's market.
Vanessa shows you the real prices of the homes you are looking at, so you can replace the assumptions with actual figures.
Sources
Calculation rules checked in November 2026 (2026 welcome tax). Estimate only: this is not financial advice.
- LégisQuébec, Act respecting duties on transfers of immovables (in French)
- City of Montréal, how transfer duties are calculated (in French)
- CMHC, cost of mortgage loan insurance
- FCAC, down payment
General information: it does not replace legal, tax or financial advice.